About 1 in 5 illnesses were linked to leafy green vegetables, the CDC found. (Rogelio V. Solis/Associated Press) A big U.S. government study has fingered leafy greens like lettuce and spinach as the leading source of food poisoning, a perhaps uncomfortable conclusion for health officials who want us to eat our vegetables.
"Most meals are safe," said Dr. Patricia Griffin, a government researcher and one of the study's authors who said the finding shouldn't discourage people from eating produce. Experts repeated often-heard advice: Be sure to wash those foods or cook them thoroughly.
While more people may have gotten sick from plants, more died from contaminated poultry, the study also found. The results were released Tuesday by the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Each year roughly 1 in 6 Americans — or 48 million people — gets sick from food poisoning. That includes 128,000 hospitalization and 3,000 deaths, according to previous CDC estimates.
It's estimated there are about 11 million cases of foodborne illness in Canada every year, according to the Canadian Food Inspection Agency's website.
The new report is the most comprehensive CDC has produced on the sources of food poisoning, covering the years 1998 through 2008. It reflects the agency's growing sophistication at monitoring illnesses and finding their source.
What jumped out at the researchers was the role fruits and vegetables played in food poisonings, said Griffin, who heads the CDC office that handles foodborne infection surveillance and analysis.
About 1 in 5 illnesses were linked to leafy green vegetables — more than any other type of food. And nearly half of all food poisonings were attributed to produce in general, when illnesses from other fruits and vegetables were added in. It's been kind of a tough month for vegetables.
A controversy erupted when Taco Bell started airing a TV ad for its variety 12-pack of tacos, with a voiceover saying that bringing a vegetable tray to a football party is "like punting on fourth-and-1." It said that people secretly hate guests who bring vegetables to parties.
Hygiene standards on farms
The fast-food chain on Monday announced it was pulling the commercial after receiving complaints that it discouraged people from eating vegetables.
Without actually saying so, the CDC report suggests that the U.S. Food and Drug Administration should devote more staff time and other resources to inspection of fruits and vegetables, said Michael Doyle, director of the University of Georgia's Center for Food Safety.
Earlier this month, the FDA released a proposed new rule for produce safety that would set new hygiene standards for farm workers and for trying to reduce contact with animal waste and dirty water.
Meanwhile, CDC officials emphasized that their report should not be seen as discouraging people from eating vegetables. Many of the vegetable-related illnesses come from norovirus, which is often spread by cooks and food handlers. So contamination sometimes has more to do with the kitchen or restaurant it came from than the food itself, Griffin noted.
Also, while vegetable-related illnesses were more common, they were not the most dangerous. The largest proportion of foodborne illness deaths — about 1 in 5 — were due to poultry. That was partly because three big outbreaks more than 10 years ago linked to turkey deli meat.
But it was close. CDC estimated 277 poultry-related deaths in 1998-2008, compared to 236 vegetable-related deaths. Fruits and nuts were credited with 96 additional deaths, making 334 total deaths for produce of all types. The CDC estimated 417 deaths from all kinds of meat and poultry, another 140 from dairy and 71 from eggs.
Red meat was once seen as one of the leading sources of food poisoning, partly because of a deadly outbreak of E. coli associated with hamburger. But Griffin and Doyle said there have been significant safety improvements in beef handling. In the study, beef was the source of fewer than 4 per cent of food-related deaths and fewer than 7 per cent of illnesses.
Dr. Atul Verma was excited to find an implantable defibrillator that worked not only for his patient's heart but also her brain monitoring needs. (Courtesy Southlake)
Researchers in an American study found that only 11 per cent of women seeking an abortion used contraception. (REUTERS/Cheryl Ravelo )
Randomized control trials do not support that snacking contributes to weight gain but the type and size of snacks matter. (Peter Dejong/Associated Press)
Retired infantryman Brendan Marrocco uses his transplanted arm to brush his hair back. (Gail Burton/Associated Press)
The FDA says GermBullet's website includes false and misleading promotional statements. (Germbullet.com)
Food, water, vaccinations and pills are all considerations for travellers, said Dr. Jay Keystone. (David MacIntosh/CBC))
Survival after breast-conserving therapy when combined with radiation is at least equivalent to mastectomy for early-stage cancers, researchers say. (Torin Halsey/The Wichita Times-Record-News)
A female deer mouse has a monitor attached to her left ear at the Adirondack Ecological Center in Newcomb, N.Y., Wednesday, Oct. 3, 2007. The Hantavirus disease is spread through the animal's urine and droppings. (The Associated Press)
Students were asked if they consumed alcohol along with energy drinks in the previous year. (Jack Dempsey/Associated Press)
Doctors called the use of NSAIDs an avoidable cause of acute kidney injury in children. (Bruno Domingos/Reuters)
A portion of a letter from Health Sciences North administration to hospital employees that highlights a new hospital protocol to protect patients during flu season. (Hilary Duff/CBC)
Joe Pilon, chief operating officer of Sudbury's Health Sciences North. (CBC)
Dr. Damian Cruse adjusts EEG sensors that his team uses to check for neurological activity in people thought to be in a vegetative state. (Courtesy UWO)
Japan tourists point to the sights around dock where the cruise ship The Queen Elizabeth 2 is docked following a norovirus outbreak. (Marco Garcia/Associated Press)
The new labels will apply to the six statins sold in Canada. (Robert F. Bukaty/Associated Press)
Lynn and John Philippe fought the provincial government to develop a catastrophic drug plan to help people struggling to pay for prescription drugs. (CBC)
Women who smoke like men die like men, researchers say. (Jonathan Alcorn/Reuters)
A man leaves a 7-Eleven store with a Double Gulp drink, in New York, where opponents of the city's limit on the size of sugary drinks are raising questions of racial fairness alongside other complaints. (Richard Drew/Associated Press)
Ron Fouchier said his bird flu experiments in ferrets could resume in weeks. (Courtesy of Ron Fouchier/Science )